CivicFM
San Jose

· 1 item

City Council, Friday, October 2

On the episode: Council splits on downtown parking rates; detention facility moratorium adopted

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Friday, October 2

1 item

The recording · Agenda

Study session on infrastructure financing tools: Community Facilities Districts and Enhanced Infrastructure Financing Districts Item 26-1054

Bonds and debtEconomic developmentTaxes and fees

An informational study session, with no vote, in which city staff and the city's municipal advisor, Fieldman Rolapp, explained two tools California cities can use to pay for public infrastructure that supports development. The first is the Community Facilities District (CFD, or Mello-Roos district). It levies a new special tax, needs approval from two-thirds of voters or landowners, and can be bonded against fairly quickly. The second is the Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District (EIFD). It adds no new tax and needs no vote to form, but it sets aside future growth in property tax, and staff said it can take five to ten years or more before that growth is large enough to borrow against. The presiding officer, chairing, said he asked for the session in his March message, to learn how the tools could support jobs, housing and downtown revitalization. Staff said the session authorizes nothing. What's at stake for residents: San Jose gets about 13.5% of the 1% property tax collected in its area. Staff said that small share limits what an EIFD would raise. Their made-up example of a $10 billion mixed-use development would support about $138 million in city-only borrowing. Staff also said the council policy that governs CFDs that borrow money, last amended in 1993, is out of date. 00:00:47

▶ Hear it Is a property-tax growth district worth it for San Jose? · 1:04

  • The presiding officer said he asked for the study session to learn how infrastructure financing tools could help investment in jobs, housing and downtown revitalization 00:00:47
  • City staff stressed that the session is only for information and does not authorize forming any district or structure 00:02:45
  • City staff went through the history: redevelopment agencies authorized in 1945, the 1982 Mello-Roos Act creating CFDs, redevelopment agencies dissolved in 2012, EIFDs created in 2014, and EIFDs streamlined in 2019 00:04:48
  • City staff explained that a CFD creates a new special tax, while an EIFD funds infrastructure from future growth in property tax without raising taxes 00:06:05
  • City staff said a CFD needs two-thirds approval from voters or landowners, while an EIFD needs no vote to form but must go through a set series of public hearings 00:07:06
  • City staff said a CFD can sometimes be set up in less than a year 00:08:06
  • City staff noted that San Jose already has a Convention Center Facilities District, a special tax paid by hotel property owners that goes back into the convention center 00:08:06
  • City staff said an EIFD is much slower, because new property value has to build up before it can be borrowed against, which could take five, eight, ten years or more 00:09:07
  • A speaker said, speaking for Public Works, that bonds from a CFD can pay for roads, public parking, streetlights, parks, water and sewer, and flood control 00:12:52
  • A speaker said CFDs can fund added services but cannot replace services that existed before the district was formed 00:13:55
  • City staff gave a made-up CFD example: 65 units on one acre needing about $5 million of streets, water and sewer work, bonded over about 30 years 00:14:07
  • City staff said the example works out to about $4,500 of special tax per unit per year, or about $378 per unit per month once debt service is added 00:15:07
  • A speaker said Council Policy 1-14, last amended in 1993, sets a $10 million minimum for the council to consider a new CFD that borrows money 00:15:51
  • A speaker said the policy also requires 1,000 single-family homes, a density that may not fit the Envision 2040 general plan, and called the policy out of date and in need of an update 00:15:51
  • A speaker said the made-up CFD example would not meet the policy's minimums 00:16:54
  • City staff explained that agencies taking part in an EIFD commit all or part of their share of new property tax, either to pay costs as they go or to repay bonds 00:17:06
  • City staff listed what an EIFD can fund, including highways, roads, water systems, public safety, civic facilities, parks, site preparation and affordable housing 00:18:08
  • City staff said, citing the county controller's figures, that the city's share of new property tax is 13.5%, school districts get 44%, the county 18%, and other taxing entities 24% 00:20:11
  • City staff said school districts' share can never go into an EIFD, while most other taxing entities can choose whether to commit their share 00:21:14
  • City staff said a made-up $10 billion mixed-use development would, once mature, support about $9 million a year in debt payments from the city's share alone, or about $138 million of bonds over 30 years at 5% interest, and called that yield somewhat modest 00:22:16
  • City staff mentioned a state transportation infrastructure loan program that could stretch borrowing capacity further, with conditions attached 00:23:16
  • City staff said an EIFD needs a separate public financing authority with a lot of administration and reporting, and can pay costs as it goes, repay developers, or issue bonds 00:24:16
  • City staff compared San Francisco, a combined city and county with a single school district that captures about 64 of the yield, with San Jose's roughly 13% share spread among dozens of school and special districts 00:26:19
  • A guest presenter explained that under state law an EIFD's public financing authority has five members: three elected officials from the participating bodies and two members of the public who live or work in the district 00:30:13
  • A guest presenter described the protest hearing: under 25% protest the district goes ahead, between 25% and 50% an election must be held within 90 days, and over 50% stops it 00:32:17
  • A guest presenter clarified that private developers can build market-rate housing inside an EIFD, but housing paid for with EIFD increment or bonds must be affordable 00:34:17
  • A guest presenter cautioned that committing the city's property tax share to an EIFD requires weighing the effect on the city's future ability to pay for everyday services 00:35:20
  • A guest presenter explained that business owners inside a CFD who are neither registered voters there nor landowners cannot vote on forming it 00:37:22
  • A guest presenter described the $10 billion example's bonding capacity as $238 million, after the staff slide had said $138 million 00:40:25
  • A guest presenter said timing usually points to using CFDs early in a project and EIFDs later 00:40:25
  • A guest presenter said developers benefit because the tools let them borrow at tax-exempt interest rates instead of higher construction-loan rates 00:41:26
  • A guest presenter described Sacramento's Aggie Square EIFD, formed in 2021 together with a CFD, where a city policy sends 80% of the increment to infrastructure and 20% to affordable housing 00:43:29
  • A guest presenter described West Sacramento's EIFD, formed in 2017 over a little more than 4,100 acres in 14 subareas, which issued bonds in 2025 00:45:30
  • A guest presenter described the Placentia EIFD from 2019, a city-county partnership, and the Eastern Coachella Valley EIFD from 2023, both of which will take years to produce usable value 00:46:30
  • A guest presenter noted that the Eastern Coachella Valley district covers 91,000 mostly undeveloped acres and includes 20% of the county's increment 00:47:32
  • A guest presenter described San Francisco's Treasure Island financing district, formed in 2017 on a former naval station with 8,000 homes and 300 acres of parks, as a success 00:48:35
  • City staff suggested questions for judging future proposals, starting with whether the investment enables development that would not otherwise happen 00:49:57
  • City staff said the city could set up a policy framework or decision tree ahead of time for ranking projects and deciding how much increment to commit 00:51:05
  • City staff said Public Works, Transportation, Finance, and to some extent planning and housing staff took part in working-group meetings on the session 00:52:09
  • A speaker asked who pays the costs of issuing CFD bonds and of compliance, and whether the city does 00:53:07
  • A guest presenter answered that issuance costs come out of bond proceeds and ongoing administration out of the special tax, so the city does not pay, though those costs reduce borrowing capacity 00:54:39
  • A speaker asked whether an EIFD built on the city's share alone would be worth the effort 00:55:44
  • A guest presenter agreed that 13.5% is not a big share and said generating only $138 million from such a development may not be worth it 00:56:02
  • A speaker pointed to Measure T's success and said going directly to voters seems more practical than these tools 00:56:55
  • A speaker said she does not think the tools are appropriate right now, noting that affordable housing does not bring in property tax 00:57:55
  • A speaker said the city has a lot of aging infrastructure and must start thinking about how to pay for it 00:59:04
  • The presiding officer responded that the tools are not only for affordable housing and may be useful at some specific sites in the city even today 00:59:40
  • A speaker asked what income-level requirements apply to housing funded by tax increment, citing a state code section that lists housing for very low to moderate incomes as eligible 00:59:54
  • A guest presenter offered to follow up afterward with the specific requirements 01:00:42
  • A speaker said he is interested in using tax increment to support mixed-income housing while keeping properties on the tax rolls 01:01:35
  • A speaker suggested EIFDs could add to funding for the city's existing alternative housing finance efforts 01:02:58
  • A speaker pointed to Google's Downtown West, approved after years of negotiation and then stalled when the market turned, and asked how forming a district would fit with land assembly and negotiations with developers 01:02:58
  • City staff said each case would be judged on its own, ideally starting once land is already assembled and there is a clear development plan, and that hotel and sales tax gains could also be considered 01:04:33
  • A speaker summed up the council's homework as updating the CFD rules and getting the city ready to move quickly on large projects with assembled land, rather than forming a district now 01:05:58
  • A speaker asked whether staff had modeled any particular areas of the city 01:06:34
  • City staff declined to discuss specific locations, saying it could distort landowners' behavior 01:07:16
  • A speaker asked whether the county took part in Sacramento's Aggie Square EIFD, where the city's share was 22.6% 01:07:58
  • A guest presenter answered that Aggie Square is a city-only EIFD, in partnership with Wexford and UC Davis 01:08:30
  • The presiding officer asked how the CFD and EIFD work together at Aggie Square, as a possible model for combining the two 01:09:24
  • A guest presenter explained that CFD bonds can be issued once phase one is built, and the expectation is that tax increment from that phase will cover the debt payments instead of levying the special tax 01:11:01
  • The presiding officer asked what made county participation possible in some examples and what shared benefits might encourage it 01:11:50
  • A guest presenter said Riverside County joined in Eastern Coachella Valley because a large undeveloped area needs infrastructure it wants built sooner 01:12:11
  • A speaker noted that special districts and water districts, not only the county, can be EIFD partners 01:12:53
  • The presiding officer asked whether school districts are left out by practice or by law, and the answer given was by law 01:13:15
  • A guest presenter warned that agencies with small shares usually need a bigger partner, and that some agencies elsewhere that formed EIFDs without one now feel their hands are tied 01:13:35
  • City staff said the memo shows the county-wide distribution and she can share a breakdown of the other taxing entities 01:15:13
  • The presiding officer said San Jose's share seems low for the city's size and services, and asked what drives it and whether reform is possible 01:15:31
  • City staff pointed to a state bill adopted last year on EIFDs for commercial-to-residential conversions, and said she would need to research whether it changed the share available to cities 01:16:20
  • A speaker said there probably has been no state bill in the last decade rebalancing the shares, only fixes for specific projects 01:17:08
  • A speaker confirmed that the 13.5% is a share of the 1% property tax, and asked for a concrete San Jose case where an EIFD would beat a CFD 01:17:48
  • City staff declined to name a specific site, saying near-term CFD revenue could build momentum toward a broader EIFD 01:18:23
  • A speaker asked what measure the city would use in five or ten years to tell whether a tool delivered the promised benefits 01:19:12
  • City staff said that by the end of a district's life the added land value and other tax revenue should be greater than the cost of the investment 01:19:52
  • A speaker asked how the long wait for revenue fits with developers needing infrastructure money upfront 01:20:27
  • City staff acknowledged, in reply to an earlier question, that the staff time and consultants needed for analysis bring near-term costs and extra workload 01:23:12

Write to the City Council about this

Public comment

  • One speaker, on Zoom; the clerk said no one signed up in person. The speaker urged the council to use these tools beyond housing: parks, trails and tree canopy (saying the trail network still has 33 miles to finish), projects that make streets pedestrian-only, and transit-plus-housing projects along East Santa Clara Street, the Stevens Creek corridor and another corridor (name garbled), plus financing to bring BART downtown.

What's next

  • The study session took no action and authorized nothing; staff said it is informational only.
  • A guest presenter offered to follow up with a speaker on the specific income-level requirements for housing funded by EIFD tax increment.
  • City staff said she would share the breakdown of the 'other taxing entities' share of property tax (community colleges, special districts and others).
  • City staff said she would research whether last year's state bill on EIFDs for commercial-to-residential conversions changed the share of increment available to cities.
  • Staff called Council Policy 1-14 on CFDs that borrow money (last amended 1993) out of date and in need of an update; no date was set for bringing an update.
  • City staff raised the idea of a city policy framework or decision tree for judging future EIFD/CFD proposals; it was not formally directed.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: city.clerk@sanjoseca.gov or its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error