· 5 items
Planning Commission, Friday, October 23
On the episode: Council steers housing study toward transit, accepts police auditor report
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Planning Commission Friday, October 23
5 items
Welcome and Planning Director's overview Item 3
Zoning and plansState and federal policyData centers
The commission's annual retreat, a study session with no votes. The Planning Director gave an overview of the department's workload. He said two things dominate it: data centers, with a new city data center policy heading to the commission and then the City Council, and the flood of state housing and land-use laws, which he said now drive most of the city's long-range planning work. 00:01:09
- City staff said a new data center policy would come to the commission next month on its way to the City Council in early December 00:02:11
- City staff said the legislature took up 1,800 bills in the last session, 300 of them on planning-related issues 00:03:16
- City staff said about 90% of the citywide planning work plan is state-mandated work or work responding to new state laws, crowding out council priorities 00:04:20
- City staff said this week's council discussion of the work plan reopened conversation about the missing middle housing items from the four-year review 00:05:21
Builder's Remedy, Housing Element and SB 79 updates Item 4
Housing supplyZoning and plansAffordable housing
Planning staff explained where things stand on three state housing rules. Builder's Remedy let developers bypass San Jose's general plan and zoning while the city lacked a state-certified housing element. The housing element itself is the city's state-required plan to make room for about 62,000 new homes by 2031. SB 79 is a new state law allowing housing within half a mile of many transit stations. Together these determine where housing can go in San Jose, and how much say the city and the commission have over it. 00:06:07
▶ Hear it Is the Builder's Remedy penalty too severe for cities? · 0:56
- City staff explained that Builder's Remedy is a penalty on cities without a certified housing element, letting qualifying projects ignore general plan and zoning 00:06:33
- City staff said the city can deny a qualifying project only by proving a specific adverse impact on public health and safety, and the burden is on the city 00:07:35
- City staff said such denials are very rare and he could not recall San Jose doing it 00:09:04
- City staff gave the required affordability options as 7% extremely low, 10% very low or 13% lower income 00:13:01
- City staff said staff worked with the developer of the Camden project to make sure its very-low-income for-sale units could actually be filled 00:11:54
- City staff said the city received 33 SB 330 preliminary applications between February and December 2023, and 24 of them became formal applications 00:13:17
- City staff said eight have been approved and two are pending, including a Topgolf ministerial permit and 741 South Winchester, which comes to the commission on appeal on November 4 00:13:48
- City staff said three applications were withdrawn, two found a different path and 11 remain under review or inactive 00:14:50
- A commissioner asked whether the consequences of lacking a housing element are too severe, given they let anyone build regardless of zoning 00:15:09
- City staff agreed the penalty is very severe and said the city took over two and a half years to write and certify its housing element 00:15:52
- City staff said the city plans to start the next housing element at the start of 2028 because it is due in January 2031 00:16:59
- City staff said cities out of compliance can face further penalties, including losing the ability to issue building permits or action by the Attorney General 00:18:40
- City staff said the eight approved projects total 697 units and replace a mix of uses 00:19:46
- City staff listed existing uses being replaced, including medical offices, restaurants, retail, Little League fields and an elementary school 00:19:46
- City staff said permits carry a two-year entitlement with an option to extend two more years to start construction 00:21:04
- City staff cited the 1655 Berryessa Road project of 62 townhomes beside the Berryessa BART station as an example of lower density than the city would want 00:21:20
- City staff said none of the approved Builder's Remedy projects has broken ground yet 00:22:11
- City staff said the housing element has over 130 programs whose progress the city must report to the state each year 00:24:46
- City staff said penalties come from failing to carry out promised actions rather than from missing the housing target itself 00:27:06
- City staff said the city had to show sites for 62,200 units on roughly 500 sites under the state's realistic-capacity rules 00:30:50
- City staff said the goal is to finish the next housing element by June 2030, ahead of the January 2031 deadline 00:32:56
- City staff said the city has produced several thousand units a year but has generally fallen far behind its targets, and offered to send the figures 00:34:20
- City staff said the biggest barrier is approved units that have not moved to construction because of economics 00:36:40
- City staff said three projects have been approved through the city's staff-level ministerial process adopted in December 2024, in about 100 days 00:36:40
- City staff said residential entitlements previously took about eight to nine months at the fastest and up to two to three years 00:38:12
- City staff said getting applicants' plans to completeness takes the longest, and staff are exploring earlier joint review with developers 00:40:30
- A commissioner suggested the city offer some kind of class to help developers submit complete applications 00:41:21
- A commissioner asked what penalties the city faces if it does not reach its housing allocation 00:43:05
- City staff said the allocation is an aspirational goal and a capacity the city must show, since the city itself does not build housing 00:44:44
- City staff said SB 79 took effect July 1 and covers about 56 light rail, Caltrain and BART stations in or near San Jose 00:45:23
- City staff said five industrial areas were exempted, and since July 1 the city has received no formal applications and one preliminary application 00:47:25
- City staff said staff will likely not pursue the exemption for sites lacking a one-mile walking path and will explain why in an information memo 00:49:30
- City staff said staff are drafting an ordinance defining demolition for historic resources, targeted for the commission in November 00:51:33
State legislative changes and updates Item 5
State and federal policyHousing supplyZoning and plans
A senior deputy city attorney and planning staff walked through new state laws that limit local control over housing. These include the Starter Home Revitalization Act amendments, AB 1751, which allows by-right townhomes starting January 1, density bonus changes, a second ADU per lot, a CEQA exemption for the Diridon Station modernization, and environmental review changes. Staff said some of these laws could replace denser housing the city planned along corridors like Stevens Creek with townhomes, and leave historic properties unprotected. 00:52:14
▶ Hear it Why would a state housing law allow downzoning? · 0:58
- City staff said 1,800 bills went through the legislature this session, 300 related to planning, and 1,100 reached the governor 00:55:23
- City staff said he does not think the city will ever meet its housing target and would be lucky to reach half 00:56:24
- City staff said starter home subdivisions must be approved or denied within 60 days of a complete application or they are deemed approved 01:00:08
- City staff said qualifying starter home projects are capped at 10 units on 10 lots 01:02:14
- City staff described a proposal in the Rose Garden neighborhood to carve off a Mills Act historic home and subdivide lots around it 01:07:31
- City staff said that case, later dropped, showed the law has no protections for historic properties; SB 1116 changes take effect January 1, 2027 01:08:39
- City staff said AB 1751, signed September 29, creates a ministerial by-right path for townhomes that goes straight to building permit 01:09:40
- City staff warned that after January someone could build townhomes at about 22 units an acre on multifamily corridors like Stevens Creek, overriding city zoning 01:12:48
- A commissioner asked why the state would allow down zoning when its direction has been toward more housing 01:15:05
- City staff said the city carried that concern to the bill's author and the governor's office 01:15:28
- City staff said raising the urban residential minimum density to 50, discussed in the four-year review, could later exclude some sites 01:15:28
- City staff raised concern that AB 2433 lets multi-phase projects build market-rate units before the affordable units that earned their density bonus 01:18:28
- City staff said AB 956 allows two detached new ADUs per lot instead of one 01:20:38
- City staff said SB 1375, which the city helped pass, creates a CEQA exemption designed for the Diridon Station modernization 01:21:40
- City staff said AB 1457 sets a June 2031 deadline for the city's environmental justice element and strengthens outreach requirements 01:23:28
- City staff described aggressive approval deadlines in the ballot measure he called Proposition 45 and said staff hope it does not pass 01:26:34
- City staff said seven projects have been approved under the AB 130 CEQA exemption since July 2025, including several Builder's Remedy projects 01:27:34
- City staff said AB 130 projects skip transportation analysis, citing neighbor concerns over traffic and parking at a San Carlos and Gifford project heard by council Tuesday 01:28:37
- City staff warned that AB 130's tight deadlines could force staff to bring unready projects to hearing for denial 01:31:21
Data centers: background ahead of proposed city standards Item 6
Data centersZoning and plans
City Manager's Office staff answered commissioners' questions about data centers before the proposed citywide data center standards come to the commission on November 18 and the City Council on December 8. Topics included where data centers are allowed, how they are permitted, the revenue the city expects, and emissions. Staff also described a proposed change that would send appeals of data center permits straight to the City Council, where today the Planning Commission has the final say. A commissioner objected that it takes away a hearing where residents can speak; staff said it answers residents who want the council to decide controversial data center cases. 01:33:05
▶ Hear it Should data center appeals skip the Planning Commission? · 1:09
- City staff said the standards will come before the commission on November 18, so this session would not present them 01:33:05
- City staff said data centers are already allowed with a special use permit in four industrial and commercial zoning districts, which limits what the city can require 01:35:08
- City staff said the California Energy Commission leads environmental review when backup generation exceeds 50 megawatts 01:36:11
- City staff estimated a 99-megawatt data center brings about $6 million a year in utility user tax 01:39:20
- City staff estimated annual property tax at $500,000 to $1 million for a 99-megawatt data center 01:40:22
- City staff said one-time construction tax is likely closer to $17 million, and a commercial linkage fee and an energy programs fee are being proposed 01:40:22
- City staff said the proposal caps backup generators at 25 hours a year with Tier 4 certification, versus the air district's 50 hours 01:43:17
- City staff said the city's proposed requirements add to state CEQA standards even when the state leads the review 01:44:42
- City staff said council directed the standards in a May rules memo voted in June, and an August memo added community benefits, tax revenue and design 01:45:28
- City staff said the proposal sends all appeals of data center special use permits from the director's hearing to the City Council, bypassing the commission 01:48:49
- A commissioner objected that removing the commission takes away a chance for residents to give input, noting community concern and moratoriums elsewhere 01:53:04
- City staff said the appeal change responds to residents who want controversial data center decisions made by the council 01:53:20
- City staff said council directed staff to develop standards, not a moratorium, and that choice rests with the council 01:56:12
- A commissioner relayed residents' reports that no council members attend the data center listening sessions 01:57:05
- City staff said the full package goes to the commission and then to the City Council on December 8, with materials public November 10 02:02:17
- City staff said a draft at roughly 80% was presented at a community meeting last week 02:01:08
- City staff said the last community meeting drew over 300 people 02:06:25
- City staff said remaining input opportunities include the Youth Commission on October 26 and an online comment form 02:05:24
- A commissioner praised staff outreach and said he would rather see data centers in San Jose than elsewhere, with safeguards 02:08:53
- City staff estimated about 20 data centers operate in the city, mostly much smaller than the 99-megawatt ones now proposed 02:10:32
- City staff said many projects cap at 99 megawatts to stay under the Energy Commission's small power plant exemption 02:11:24
- City staff said the standards are not streamlining, citing limits on cooling systems and generator hours 02:13:58
- City staff said Santa Clara has so many data centers because its utility costs are lower than neighboring cities 02:14:38
Public comment Item 7
Data centers
Open public comment at the end of the retreat. One speaker, on Zoom, addressed the data center standards. 02:14:49
- A commissioner thanked the speaker and invited them to attend the November hearing 02:17:42
Public comment
- One speaker, who said they work for the local Sierra Club chapter and live in San Jose, criticized the data center standards. The speaker said staff working on them are funded under a PG&E implementation agreement that mentions permit streamlining. They argued data center revenue is a tiny share of the city's budget relative to the power these facilities use. They also said community feedback has overwhelmingly called the standards inadequate and the August-to-December process too short, and that residents asked for a moratorium. They cited air, noise and heat impacts and unlimited generator use during outages, and asked that data center projects go to the City Council by default.
What's next
- November 4: the Builder's Remedy project at 741 South Winchester comes to the Planning Commission on appeal.
- November 10: the data center standards package (policy, ordinances, resolutions, nexus studies) is to be released to the public.
- November 18: data center standards come to the Planning Commission; December 8: to the City Council.
- November (target): an ordinance update defining demolition for historic resources comes to the Planning Commission.
- Staff plan an information memo to the City Council, to be shared with the commission, on the SB 79 walking-path exemption, which staff do not expect to pursue.
- October 26: the Youth Commission takes up data centers in a public meeting; staff also mentioned a District 7 neighborhood association meeting in early November (date given as November 5 or 7).
- January 1, 2027: AB 1751 townhome pathway takes effect, and SB 1116 starter home changes apply going forward.
- The housing element Annual Progress Report goes to the City Council in March and is due to the state April 1.
- Work on the seventh-cycle housing element is planned to start in early 2028, with completion targeted for June 2030 ahead of the January 2031 deadline; the environmental justice element is due June 2031.
- Staff offered to send commissioners the city's annual housing production numbers.
- Staff said they are looking at an update to the transportation analysis policy.
- Staff said the ballot measure they called Proposition 45 is on the upcoming election ballot.
Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: planningsupportstaff@sanjoseca.gov