CivicFM
San Jose

· 5 items

Planning Commission, Wednesday, October 28

On the episode: Council renames downtown plaza and reworks loan for foster youth housing

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

Planning Commission Wednesday, October 28

5 items

The recording · Agenda

Consent calendar: September 9 minutes and Vallarta Supermarket alcohol permit Item 4

Development projects

Two routine items approved in one vote: the action minutes from September 9, 2026, and a Planned Development Permit with a Determination of Public Convenience or Necessity letting a future Vallarta Supermarket sell a full range of alcohol for off-site consumption (Type 21) in an existing roughly 63,737-square-foot space at 2179 Monterey Road in Council District 7 (agenda). No commissioner pulled an item. 00:06:07

  • Lawrence Casey (Commissioner) moved to approve the consent calendar, seconded by Melissa Bickford (Commissioner) (as the chair stated them); Khoi Nguyen (Commissioner), Pierluigi Oliverio (Commissioner) and Carlos Rosario (Commissioner) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 00:07:46

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Appeal of Valley Recycling's capacity increase at 1611 South 7th Street Item 5a

Trash and recyclingDevelopment projectsPollution

A neighboring RV business appealed a December 2025 director's hearing approval of a special use permit for Valley Recycling II at 1611 South 7th Street in Council District 7. The permit would raise the site's maximum daily intake of construction, demolition and inert debris from 174.99 tons to 2,451 tons, the amount staff and the agenda say the facility was designed and built for, and allow it to run 24 hours a day, 7 days a week except holidays. The appellant said dust, debris and odor from the open-air site are hurting the business and the health of its staff. Staff recommended denying the appeal. Staff said a consultant's dust study found the expanded operation would exceed a PM10 threshold, so a condition keeps the permit from taking effect until a permit adjustment carries out the study's fix: raising the perimeter fence to 25 feet and/or lowering pile heights. The environmental exemption was not before the commission because no valid appeal of it was filed. 00:08:48

  • The chair offered a substitute motion to deny the permit unless a dust mitigation plan is approved before it can be issued, seconded by a commissioner. Result: withdrawn. 01:19:21
  • A commissioner moved to approve the staff recommendation, denying the appeal and upholding the director's hearing approval of Special Use Permit SP24-029, seconded by a commissioner; Khoi Nguyen (Commissioner), Pierluigi Oliverio (Commissioner) and Carlos Rosario (Commissioner) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:23:19
  • City staff presented the request: raising the facility's permitted daily capacity from 174.99 tons to 2,451 tons and its hours to 24/7 00:09:23
  • City staff said code enforcement found no dust violation, and that the 24/7 operation had broken the state LEA permit rather than a city permit, an issue resolved before the director's hearing 00:11:32
  • City staff said the supplemental dust analysis found current operations within state and federal thresholds, but the proposed operation would exceed the PM10 threshold 00:13:46
  • City staff said the analysis recommended a 25-foot perimeter fence and/or lower tipping piles, and a condition keeps the permit from taking effect until a permit adjustment does this 00:13:46
  • The applicant's representative said the applicant supports the staff recommendation and asked the commission to deny the appeal 00:15:14
  • The applicant's representative said piles are limited to 25 feet and the fence will be raised to 25 feet 00:26:02
  • The applicant's representative said the facility cannot take more tonnage until it gets its solid waste facilities permit and air permits, and the fence must go up first 00:26:47
  • The applicant's representative said the facility has never received a violation for odor or dust, only areas of concern on other items 00:27:25
  • City staff said, as the LEA inspector, she has issued no dust or odor violations in three to four years of inspecting the site and can't cite what she doesn't see in person 00:28:27
  • City staff said she issued an area of concern for odor earlier this month after noticing an intermittent earthy odor, and that earlier record-keeping issues have been abated 00:29:33
  • City staff said two nearby construction-demolition sites run differently, and unlike them Valley Recycling operates in the open air with no roof or overhang 00:32:54
  • A commissioner questioned approving an increase before the operator shows a track record at its current capacity, comparing it to a liquor license the commission had held back 00:33:50
  • City staff said the site is surrounded by heavy industrial uses, the only designation that would allow this use, and that conditions were added for that reason 00:34:52
  • Luis Arguello (Commissioner) described dust-suppression equipment used in demolition work and asked whether the operator plans an ongoing dust-suppression system 00:37:05
  • The applicant's representative described a full-time 4,000-gallon water truck that fills about 10 times a day, plus street sweeping four to six times a day 00:38:24
  • The applicant's representative said more than 40 dust complaints have produced no violations from the LEA or the air district 00:38:24
  • City staff clarified that piles will stay the same height, since the operator chose the taller fence over lowering the piles 00:41:03
  • City staff explained that the LEA is state-funded but sits within city code enforcement 00:42:28
  • Michael Young (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning Commission) argued that the commission decides only whether the land use is appropriate, with dust and odor left to the LEA and the air district, then moved the staff recommendation 00:43:36
  • The applicant's representative said a bigger, more permanent sprinkler or dust-control system is planned in about six to nine months, though it was not in the original plans 00:46:33
  • The chair questioned how the operator could handle a much larger volume without hazards to neighbors if it can't process its current volume fast enough 00:53:37
  • The applicant's representative said the 2,451-ton cap is a safeguard for large one-time loads such as soil or concrete, and would rarely if ever be reached 00:58:00
  • A commissioner said the vote concerns land use, with air quality handled at other checkpoints, and backed the original motion 01:03:17
  • City staff said the dust study found prevailing winds blow mostly southeast, toward the adjacent 1615 parcel rather than the appellant's site 01:06:19
  • A commissioner argued that heavy industrial areas are where this kind of work belongs, and staff agreed 01:10:42
  • Michael Young (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning Commission) confirmed with staff that the facility was originally designed for the requested capacity 01:11:57
  • City staff said environmental review found the project exempt from CEQA as an existing facility 01:12:27
  • Michael Young (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning Commission) argued that mitigation measures aren't appropriate since no CEQA approval was needed, and noted the facility predates the complainants 01:13:04
  • City staff described the site's operations plan as enforceable through code enforcement, with watering, sweeping and equipment spray requirements 01:14:15
  • City staff said the operations plan estimates water use rising from 700 to 2,000 gallons a day under the proposal 01:15:20
  • Michael Young (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning Commission) pointed out that only two people came to oppose, compared with the dozens problem projects usually draw 01:16:33
  • City staff advised that the substitute motion's maker would need to make findings to deny the permit 01:17:38
  • Michael Young (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning Commission) said enforcing dust rules is up to code enforcement and state agencies, not the commission, and opposed the substitute motion 01:19:01
  • The chair withdrew the substitute motion after learning the facility was designed for the requested volume 01:19:21
  • A commissioner said the neighbors knew a recycling center was there when they moved in, and backed the original motion as a land-use vote 01:19:54
  • The chair said he would vote yes because the use is not changing significantly beyond its intended design 01:22:19

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Amendment to Apple's Orchard Parkway development agreement Item 5b

Development projectsBiking and walkingEnergy

The commission was asked to recommend that the City Council approve a first amendment to Apple's development agreement for its roughly 86-acre North San Jose site on Orchard Parkway in Council District 4. The agreement allows 4,150,000 square feet of development, and staff said about 487,000 square feet, or roughly 12%, is built so far. The amendment would take 9.7 acres fronting North 1st Street out of the agreement for sale to PG&E, which staff said publicly intends to build a substation there. It also anticipates a conditional vacation of the stretch of Orchard Parkway between Atmel Way and Component Drive, and part of Atmel Way. That vacation is a separate City Council action, triggered by Apple filing a permit for its next building, approved improvement plans, and a notice of intent to close the streets. In return, Apple would pay $2,500,000 toward a bike and pedestrian crossing at Trimble Road, install protected Class IV bike lanes on Component Drive, and give $90,000 to the Transit Priority Signal Fund ($30,000 each for the Trimble, Component and Charcot intersections with North 1st Street). Public speakers and VTA objected to losing Orchard Parkway as a bike route; VTA also opposed a substation next to the light rail station, and other speakers tied the substation to a proposed data center. Staff dropped the General Plan consistency finding from its recommendation. 01:23:19

  • A commissioner moved staff's recommendation as shown on the slide: recommend that the City Council adopt a resolution approving the addendum to the North San Jose Development Policies, Envision San José 2040 and BEA Development Project EIRs, and approve the ordinance adopting the First Amendment to the Amended and Restated Development Agreement with Apple Inc.; seconded by a commissioner; Khoi Nguyen (Commissioner), Pierluigi Oliverio (Commissioner) and Carlos Rosario (Commissioner) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 02:14:52
  • City staff said the agreement allows 4,150,000 square feet on the site, and about 487,000 square feet has been built in two buildings 01:26:16
  • City staff said the amendment removes 9.7 acres fronting North 1st Street for a sale to PG&E 01:28:19
  • City staff described the conditional vacation of Orchard Parkway between Atmel Way and Component Drive, plus part of Atmel Way 01:28:19
  • City staff said the vacations happen only after Apple files a permit for its next building, improvement plans are approved, and Apple gives notice of intent to close the streets 01:29:21
  • City staff listed Apple's contributions: $2,500,000 for a Trimble Road bike and pedestrian crossing, and Class IV bike lanes on Component Drive 01:29:21
  • City staff added a $90,000 contribution to the Transit Priority Signal Fund, $30,000 for each of three North 1st Street intersections 01:29:21
  • City staff said the commission does not act on the street vacation, which the City Council decides while Public Works processes it 01:30:25
  • City staff said the environmental addendum found no new or more severe significant impacts and no need for new mitigation 01:35:03
  • City staff said staff dropped the General Plan consistency finding from its recommendation 01:35:34
  • The chair disclosed a recent conversation with an Apple representative and said he had read the speakers' letters 01:48:28
  • City staff confirmed the amendment is consistent with the Envision 2040 General Plan and the 2016 agreement 01:50:00
  • Luis Arguello (Commissioner) said he would move approval if the site were in his district 01:50:29
  • A commissioner stressed that the decision concerns land Apple owns, not a data center 01:51:19
  • City staff said a PG&E substation would go through a separate approval and that PG&E is largely exempt from city land-use review 01:53:16
  • City staff confirmed that PG&E is regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission, not the city's land-use process 01:53:42
  • A commissioner framed the question as whether Apple's concessions make up for the streets and public access the city would give up 01:54:02
  • City staff said the action shrinks the development agreement's footprint to keep the site buildable as a campus 01:54:47
  • City staff said staff will bring a data center item to the City Council in December 01:55:52
  • City staff said Orchard Parkway is an easement over land that would revert to the underlying property owner 01:56:54
  • City staff said Apple is not proposing a data center and the site isn't seen as one, and that nearby data centers are unrelated to this action 01:57:56
  • A commissioner moved the staff recommendation, citing Apple's interest in building non-data-center business space in District 4 01:58:50
  • City staff confirmed that the area along the 1st Street light rail station is suitable for transit-oriented development 02:00:21
  • City staff said a traffic study routes pedestrians around via North 1st Street, and no bike access through Orchard Parkway has been considered 02:01:01
  • City staff advised that the city can't dictate where Apple carves off the parcel or where the substation goes, though it could raise health and safety issues with the CPUC 02:04:50
  • City staff pointed to existing substations near downtown and said the city's influence over major utility projects is limited 02:06:22
  • City staff said Component Drive has no bike lanes now, and Apple would install the protected Class IV lanes in the city's plans 02:08:20
  • City staff said Apple's Trimble crossing improvement is meant to keep the flood-prone section of the Guadalupe River Trail open in winter 02:09:44
  • City staff said the data center raised in public comment has not been approved and is a separate project several blocks away 02:10:43
  • City staff said data center standards coming to the commission in two weeks would include a proposal to send data center appeals straight to the City Council 02:11:28
  • The chair said the commission doesn't review the street closure or the data center, and urged residents to raise those concerns with their councilmember 02:13:01
  • The chair called a substation on that street unattractive and hoped the city would work with PG&E on a better approach 02:13:01

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Citywide zoning and tree-code cleanup ordinance Item 5c

Zoning and plansParks and treesHistoric preservation

A package of amendments to Title 13 and Title 20 of the Municipal Code, sent to the City Council with an advisory recommendation. In High and Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones, it would let owners use the streamlined 'unsuitable tree' removal process for trees 5 to 100 feet from a home, capped at 10 trees per lot in the 30-to-100-foot zone, and pay an in-lieu fee instead of replanting on site. It adds a stricter definition of demolition for properties on the Historic Resource Inventory, so that CEQA review still applies when they are substantially altered. Other changes: updated SB 9 historic-district rules under AB 1061; ADU rules allowing combinations that could yield five units on a single-family lot, including the main home; a legally nonconforming use could sit unused for up to three years, instead of six months, before losing its status, with no special use permit to reinstate it; retaining walls up to four feet would need no planning permit, four to seven feet an administrative permit, and seven feet or more a special use permit; vehicle gates for developments of up to 50 units could get an administrative permit. Per the agenda, it would also lengthen the noticing period from 10 to 20 days under AB 2904 and make other definitional and technical fixes. 02:14:52

  • A commissioner moved to approve the staff recommendation, recommending that the City Council adopt the ordinance and consider the CEQA determination of consistency; seconded by a speaker; Dilpreet Bhandal (Commissioner) had left, and Khoi Nguyen (Commissioner), Pierluigi Oliverio (Commissioner) and Carlos Rosario (Commissioner) were absent. Result: passed, 7-0. 02:28:19
  • City staff said the streamlined removal process would extend to defensible-space zones one and two in high fire hazard areas 02:17:16
  • City staff said zone-two removals through the streamlined process would be capped at 10 trees per lot 02:18:17
  • City staff said paying the city's in-lieu replacement fee would be acceptable in high fire hazard zones 02:19:17
  • City staff proposed a new demolition definition for historic inventory properties so that CEQA review still applies under SB 79 and AB 130 02:21:19
  • City staff said ADU combinations allowed by state law could yield five units on a single-family lot, and more changes are coming for ADU laws signed in September 02:22:22
  • City staff said that, per council direction, the lapse period for legal nonconforming uses would go from six months to three years, ending the special use permit requirement 02:23:31
  • City staff proposed raising the planning-permit threshold for retaining walls from two feet to four feet 02:23:31
  • City staff said four-to-seven-foot walls would need an administrative permit and walls seven feet or taller a special use permit 02:24:34
  • City staff said vehicle gates meeting safety rules for developments of up to 50 units could be approved by administrative permit 02:24:34
  • City staff said the one public comment received, on tree removal, was outside the update's scope 02:25:42
  • City staff said the airport land use commission found the ordinance consistent and the City Council will hear it on November 17, 2026 02:26:45
  • City staff pointed out that the public hearing had not been opened for comment before the motion 02:27:31

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Good and welfare: council report and 2027 meeting schedule Item 6

Staff reported on recent City Council actions on items the commission had handled. Approving the 2027 Planning Commission meeting schedule was on the agenda, but the commission skipped it because the packet held the 2026 schedule instead. 02:28:19

  • No motion; approval of the 2027 Planning Commission meeting schedule was skipped. Result: no action. 02:30:49
  • City staff reported that on September 15 the council took up reasonable accommodation code amendments, a planned development permit on Cottle Road, and an appeal of a Builder's Remedy project 02:28:52
  • City staff reported that on September 29 the council heard the Sakura Market permit at 184 South Market, and that staff also brought the citywide planning work plan prioritization and an early consideration of a general plan change and an environmental appeal 02:28:52
  • A commissioner pointed out that the agenda attachment was the 2026 calendar, not 2027 02:30:15
  • City staff said staff would look into it and bring the schedule back at the next meeting 02:30:31

Write to the Planning Commission about this

Public comment

  • General public comment (non-agenda items): no speakers. One speaker card listed no agenda item, and the chair asked staff to help that person; he later spoke on item 5a.
  • Item 5a (Valley Recycling appeal): two speakers from the appellant, a neighboring family-run RV business. They described dust, debris, and lately an ammonia-like odor from the site's piles, said these have triggered serious asthma attacks and other health problems among staff, showed videos of dust coming over the fence, and said the operator has been warned repeatedly about pile height and processing times. They argued that an operator struggling at current volumes should not get a large capacity increase and 24/7 hours. One said things had improved since the complaints but were not fixed. Staff said one other community member had reached out in opposition.
  • Item 5b (Apple development agreement): five speakers, two in person and three on Zoom, all opposed or critical. A VTA principal transportation planner said VTA cannot support the project as proposed: a substation next to the light rail station conflicts with transit-oriented plans, and closing Orchard Parkway removes a low-stress bike route. VTA asked to keep bike and pedestrian access, or to require other improvements. Two bike advocates objected to closing Orchard Parkway to people walking and biking; one said it would force a long detour off the Guadalupe River Trail and asked for a sunset date, payment to the city, and a permanent bike/ped easement. A speaker from a Sierra Club chapter said the PG&E substation expansion would power a proposed data center on Charcot Avenue, objected to reviewing them separately, and asked that the whole be analyzed before any approval; two other Zoom speakers tied the deal to data centers too, one of them urging a moratorium. One more Zoom speaker was called but did not respond.
  • Item 5c (code amendments): no public speakers; staff noted one public comment received on tree removal, which it called outside the scope of the update.

What's next

  • Item 5b goes to the City Council as a recommendation on the addendum and the development agreement amendment ordinance. The Orchard Parkway and Atmel Way street vacations are a separate City Council action that Public Works is processing concurrently.
  • Staff said a data center item goes to the City Council in December, and amended data center standards, including a proposal to send data center appeals directly to the council, come to the Planning Commission in about two weeks.
  • Item 5c, the Title 13/Title 20 code amendments, goes to the City Council hearing on November 17, 2026. Staff said further ADU code changes will follow from ADU laws the governor signed in September.
  • Valley Recycling still needs a permit adjustment for the taller fence, a solid waste facilities permit, and air district permits before it can take more tonnage, according to its representative and staff.
  • Staff will bring the 2027 Planning Commission meeting schedule back at the next meeting.

Write to the Planning Commission before its next meeting: planningsupportstaff@sanjoseca.gov

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error