CivicFM
San Jose

· 4 items

City Council, Monday, November 16

What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in San Jose's next episode.

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Monday, November 16

4 items

The recording · Agenda · Agenda · Agenda

Study session introduction: who struggles with affordability in San Jose Item 1

Jobs and wagesBudgets

An informational study session, with no votes, that council asked for in its June budget message. Staff and a guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies laid out data on what basic living costs a household in San Jose and Santa Clara County, who falls short, and where in the city hardship is concentrated. The session is meant to set up the council's February priority setting and next year's budget, where the council can add affordability investments or change its focus areas. 00:00:49

  • The mayor said the session follows the direction the council gave in its June budget message on the high cost of living. 00:00:49
  • The city manager said the analysis is meant to lay the groundwork for February priority setting, where the council decides how the work shapes its focus areas. 00:02:21
  • City staff said the city's community survey added a question on affordability in the first quarter of this fiscal year. 00:06:38
  • City staff reported that survey respondents struggle most with housing, then utilities and healthcare. 00:06:38
  • City staff said once more quarters of data are in, the survey results can be broken down by ethnicity, income and council district. 00:07:40
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies presented Sobrato data that a family with two working adults and two children needs at least $166,584 a year to cover basics with no outside help. 00:09:56
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said a typical full-time worker in the valley earns about $90,000, barely half of what such a family needs. 00:09:56
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said by the self-sufficiency standard, 26% of working families in Santa Clara County cannot meet basic needs. 00:11:00
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said the federal poverty measure misses about five of every six struggling families in the county. 00:11:00
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said 70% of single mothers fall short, rising to 85% when they have a child age three or younger. 00:12:00
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said three council districts stood out on a social vulnerability index, at 75%, 67% and 61%. 00:13:05
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said residents of Downtown and East San Jose work at rates similar to or above the national rate, so the problem isn't jobs. 00:14:30
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said a single worker without a bachelor's degree in East and Downtown San Jose averages $44,000 a year, against a citywide average of $90,000. 00:14:30
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said 37% to 39% of households in Downtown and East San Jose fall short of self-sufficiency. 00:15:36
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said Sobrato organizes its investments around two goals, reducing costs and raising incomes. 00:15:36

Write to the City Council about this

Improving affordability: housing, utilities, taxes, transportation, childcare and food Item 2

Housing supplyEnergyTaxes and fees

Staff went through the main household cost categories (housing, the city-run utilities, local taxes, transportation, childcare and food), what role the city has in each, and what San Jose and other places have tried in order to bring costs down. These are the areas where city rates, permits and programs affect residents' monthly bills. This was a briefing only, with no votes. 00:17:36

  • The planning director said San Jose grew outward after World War II and had reached close to its current size, about 180 square miles, by around 1990. 00:19:07
  • The planning director said single-family homes make up about 84% of the city's residential area. 00:20:09
  • The planning director said the city's cost-of-development studies keep finding more projects that don't pencil out, many of them before land costs are even counted. 00:21:15
  • The planning director said Austin grew its housing stock by about 10.5% from 2021 to 2024, and its rents fell about 4% while rents rose across Texas and nationally. 00:23:16
  • The planning director said the main difference from San Jose is that Austin allowed two or three homes on lots that used to allow one, which San Jose is still studying. 00:23:16
  • The San Jose Clean Energy director said San Jose Clean Energy's 2026 generation rates are the lowest they have ever been, but can't be sustained long term. 00:25:41
  • The San Jose Clean Energy director said the rates are set below cost to offset a large exit fee for legacy contracts, the power charge indifference adjustment (PCIA). 00:25:41
  • City staff said about 70% of the municipal water system's operating budget goes to buying wholesale water. 00:27:00
  • City staff said the water utility has only been passing through wholesale cost increases and has absorbed its own cost increases. 00:28:01
  • City staff said municipal water bills come to about 1.3% of area median income, at or below the federal and state affordability thresholds. 00:28:01
  • City staff said garbage and recycling rates rise each year under multi-decade hauler contracts that allow an annual increase tied to an index. 00:29:04
  • City staff said the storm sewer charge, about $8 a month, hasn't changed in fifteen years, and a deferred maintenance backlog is growing as a result. 00:31:14
  • The San Jose Clean Energy director said a PCIA transparency bill the city ran passed the state legislature but was vetoed by the governor. 00:32:36
  • The San Jose Clean Energy director said the San Jose Cares program gives about 82,000 households a 10% discount on top of state discount programs. 00:32:36
  • City staff said preventive maintenance is one of the main ways the utilities keep rates down over time. 00:34:13
  • City staff said the sales tax falls hardest on lower-income households, and the rate in San Jose is currently 10%. 00:37:39
  • City staff cited a 2018 state bill, SB 993, that would have cut the sales tax on goods by 2% and made up the revenue with a new 3% tax on business-to-business services. 00:38:43
  • City staff said Measure E, the property transfer tax, exempts sales below a threshold that started at $2 million and is now $2.3 million after adjustments. 00:39:44
  • City staff said owning and running a typical vehicle costs a household about $13,000 a year, against about $990 for a VTA annual pass. 00:41:25
  • City staff said Move San Jose tracks transportation costs as a share of household income, which averages 9.7% citywide. 00:42:33
  • City staff said the East San Jose plan, En Movimiento, identifies 29 corridors for improvements. 00:42:33
  • City staff described a mobility wallet that gives eligible East San Jose residents monthly prepaid funds for transit, electric rideshare and bike share. 00:43:39
  • City staff said an on-demand electric shuttle for East San Jose, Palante, is expected to launch in about the first quarter of calendar 2027. 00:43:39
  • The San Jose Clean Energy director said fast-charging hubs coming online in 2027 will pilot low-income and subscription pricing. 00:44:50
  • The San Jose Clean Energy director said income-qualified customers can get $3,000 off a new EV and a smaller rebate on a used one. 00:44:50
  • City staff said childcare costs have grown faster than the rest of the economy, which economists call cost disease. 00:46:00
  • City staff noted the council directed in October that a revision of childcare land use rules be added to the planning department's work plan. 00:48:04
  • City staff said cities that subsidize childcare directly mostly use voter-approved taxes, such as San Francisco's 2018 commercial rent tax, which funds what staff put at over $200 million in subsidies. 00:49:05
  • City staff described a state pilot that matches SNAP spending on fruits and vegetables up to $60 a month, with four participating grocery stores in San Jose. 00:51:06

Write to the City Council about this

Helping residents grow their incomes Item 3

Jobs and wagesSmall business

Staff reviewed city efforts to help residents earn more: the library-led education strategy, the Work2Future workforce board the city hosts, the local minimum wage, and small-business loan funds used in other cities. These programs reach job seekers and workers trying to earn enough to stay in San Jose. This was a briefing only, with no votes. 00:51:55

  • A library deputy director said the SJLearns program gives school districts grants for TK through third-grade reading proficiency. 00:54:13
  • A library deputy director noted the council approved a digital empowerment and broadband strategy in December of last year, expanding digital skills programs. 00:55:15
  • City staff said Work2Future's operating budget for 2025-2026 was $14,440,000. 00:56:10
  • City staff said Work2Future served 2,422 job seekers during the year, 1,602 through federal WIOA funds and 820 through the city-funded San Jose Works program. 00:57:12
  • City staff said 300 businesses received recruitment, layoff-aversion and other business help. 00:57:12
  • City staff said the local minimum wage, set by a 2012 voter initiative and raised to $15 by 2019, is adjusted each year for inflation and now sits at $18.45 an hour. 00:58:42
  • City staff said Work2Future can fund on-the-job and incumbent worker training in partnership with employers. 00:59:38
  • City staff pointed to small-business loan funds in Vancouver, Washington and San Francisco as a way other cities help residents raise their incomes. 01:00:53
  • City staff said the study session is meant to set up council deliberation during the budget process. 01:02:38

Write to the City Council about this

Council discussion: calls for an affordability focus area, minimum wage review and better measures

Jobs and wagesAffordable housingHousing supply

After the presentations, councilmembers questioned staff and the Sobrato presenters. Several members said affordability should become an official council focus area or a lens applied to every department's work. One member proposed an affordability fund paid for by major developments including data centers, and another raised reviewing the local minimum wage. No action was taken; members said the work continues into priority setting and the budget. 01:03:37

▶ Hear it Who will vote to make affordability a council priority? · 1:00

  • The mayor said the council has spent less time on how the city can help people raise their incomes than on costs. 01:04:43
  • The mayor asked how much more research staff would need to find where city income-boosting efforts give the highest return. 01:05:43
  • City staff said most of Work2Future's budget is federal money whose allocation shifts from year to year. 01:07:21
  • The mayor said the data suggest low pay matters more than access to jobs, and asked what levers could raise incomes for people already working. 01:08:31
  • City staff said continuing to focus on traded-sector industries, where jobs tend to be more durable, will be important. 01:09:43
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said Sobrato is studying quality-job indicators beyond wages, such as benefits and time off, and offered to share that work with the city. 01:10:14
  • The mayor asked the administration to bring a data-driven view of where limited city money and staff time would most raise incomes when the topic returns in the budget process. 01:12:15
  • The mayor said by his analysis half of Austin's roughly 120,000 new homes over ten years were large multifamily buildings near transit corridors. 01:13:31
  • The mayor said another quarter of Austin's new homes were single-family sprawl, and ADUs were only about 2.4%. 01:14:32
  • The planning director said Austin's success came largely from multifamily housing, which is hard to deliver locally mainly because of construction costs. 01:15:25
  • The planning director said the city has largely caught up on permitting process, so multifamily construction now depends on the economics. 01:15:25
  • The mayor said the real answer on childcare would be a countywide funding measure like those in San Francisco and Marin, and asked how far city-level efforts alone could go. 01:16:42
  • City staff said staffing costs are the main challenge in childcare, so easing zoning likely won't bring widespread affordability changes. 01:18:01
  • Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) argued there is a difference between work that contributes to affordability and making affordability itself a measure of the city's success. 01:20:51
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said Sobrato's most important step was adopting the self-sufficiency standard as its main measure of success. 01:22:12
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said Sobrato will launch a climate action strategy in 2027 aimed at cutting family energy costs. 01:24:20
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies said 78% of Sobrato's nonprofit grantees have been directly hit by state or federal funding cuts. 01:28:32
  • A councilmember cited the Turner Center simulator's San Diego model, which suggested missing-middle reforms could add upwards of 2,000 net new units a year, and asked whether planning staff can use such tools. 01:30:36
  • The planning director said housing element reporting requirements push the city to find the highest-impact programs, and such tools are being explored. 01:31:50
  • A councilmember said San Jose's minimum wage, once a regional leader, has fallen behind Mountain View, San Francisco, Sunnyvale and Santa Clara. 01:31:55
  • A councilmember said a full-time minimum wage worker now earns about $38,000 a year, nearly $5,000 below the 30% area median income level. 01:33:00
  • A councilmember said it may be time for the council to reconsider how the minimum wage is working, while weighing the effects on small businesses. 01:34:02
  • A councilmember cited an analysis that San Jose families face the highest household bills among the largest U.S. cities, nearly $45,000 a year. 01:35:28
  • A councilmember criticized the council's vote to redirect about $40 million in Measure E money from permanent affordable housing to temporary shelter operations. 01:36:29
  • A councilmember said he sees more people living on District 5 streets despite reported drops in unsheltered homelessness. 01:36:29
  • A councilmember contrasted city efforts to accommodate data center investment with what he called reluctance to act as urgently for struggling residents. 01:37:34
  • A councilmember argued housing production can't be the only strategy because families can't wait years for the market. 01:38:40
  • A councilmember cited Henrico County, Virginia committing $60 million in data center revenue to affordable housing. 01:39:46
  • A councilmember proposed a San Jose Affordability Fund paid for by legally allowed contributions from major developments, including data centers, plus part of the new tax revenue they bring. 01:40:50
  • A councilmember called for affordability to become an official council focus area and said a council vote on it will come. 01:41:50
  • A councilmember asked what data the city would collect over time to know whether it is making a difference on affordability. 01:43:52
  • City staff said the best approach would pair the subjective survey with an objective self-sufficiency measure, which exists for the county but not yet for the city. 01:45:45
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies explained the self-sufficiency standard comes from the University of Washington's Center for Women's Welfare. 01:46:32
  • A guest presenter from Sobrato Philanthropies described a coming Silicon Valley Financial Well-being Survey with Joint Venture Silicon Valley that will survey about 4,000 residents, including on assets and wealth. 01:48:11
  • A councilmember suggested building affordability into every department's goals, as the city has done with climate and equity, with measurable outcomes. 01:49:26
  • A councilmember asked staff to come back with options for how the council could track affordability, and to suggest one or two practices from other cities to test in next year's budget. 01:53:02
  • A councilmember proposed that every staff recommendation analyze whether a policy makes life more or less expensive for residents. 01:56:52
  • Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) said removing childcare permitting barriers earlier this year saves prospective operators more than $30,000. 01:58:19
  • City staff said wealth disparity is growing nationally, and where it is falling the cause is often higher-wage jobs leaving the city. 01:59:29
  • Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) asked how the city measures whether it is becoming more affordable, including for families already priced out or displaced. 02:01:34
  • City staff suggested tracking a diversity-of-industries index, already reported in the annual economic forecast, more visibly. 02:02:51
  • City staff said staff will weigh the council's feedback, including the difference between outputs and outcomes, but had no answer yet. 02:04:33
  • Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) said she will keep pushing for a dedicated affordability focus area that brings existing efforts together. 02:07:50
  • The mayor agreed affordability should remain an ongoing priority and at minimum a key lens for the city's work. 02:08:46
  • A councilmember suggested shifting half of the new-EV rebate money toward childcare support for families. 02:09:04
  • A councilmember argued for building smaller homes so more people can afford to buy. 02:10:07
  • A councilmember asked how the city accounts for moderate-income families who can't afford market-rate childcare. 02:11:11
  • City staff said the city doesn't fund childcare co-ops but supports a family, friend and neighbor caregiver program that graduates about 50 caregivers a year. 02:13:47
  • City staff said state and county licensing frameworks limit how much the city can do to help childcare facilities expand. 02:15:17
  • The mayor said making it easier to build housing is currently the city's single most important bet on affordability. 02:17:51
  • The mayor said the session had him thinking economic development work may need to be expanded or brought further into the focus area work. 02:18:51

Write to the City Council about this

Public comment

  • About 15 people spoke, in person and online. The city clerk also read a written statement submitted as an ADA accommodation.
  • Most speakers, many from nonprofit service providers and advocacy groups and several identifying with the REAL Coalition, urged the council to make affordability an official council focus area. Two asked for clear metrics showing who is most burdened, three for a council vote on it, two of those before next year's budget, and one for a focus area on affordability and quality jobs.
  • Speakers described rising demand at service organizations, childcare costs (one said their family pays $35,000 a year for infant and after-school care), wage gaps for Latina workers (a cited median of $21 an hour against $38 regionally), immigrant families' fears about housing and healthcare, and families being priced out of San Jose.
  • One speaker argued the city's focus areas favor tech companies, contrasting rules for sidewalk delivery robots with code enforcement action against a food pantry.
  • One speaker urged making transportation affordability, and cutting how many cars households need, a higher priority, linking it to access to food.
  • One speaker argued the presentation didn't justify more housing deregulation, citing a 2021 city study on four to eight units per single-family lot, along with environmental and fiscal impacts.
  • The written statement proposed fixing base property tax rates at the time of purchase, with increases subject to voter approval, so that families can stay in their homes.
  • One speaker recounted the story of an elderly worker who was fired and now faces eviction. Another urged broadening who qualifies for assistance.

What's next

  • The study session feeds the council's February priority setting and the budget process, including the March and June budget messages, where the council can add affordability investments or change its focus areas.
  • A councilmember said a council vote on making affordability a focus area will come; three public speakers asked the council to vote on it, two of them before next year's budget process.
  • Matt Mahan (Mayor) said that when the topic returns through the budget process, it would help for the administration to have more perspective on where limited city money and staff time would most raise workers' incomes.
  • Staff will keep asking the affordability question in the city's quarterly community survey and plans to break the results down by demographics and council district once more quarters of data are in.
  • A self-sufficiency measure for the city itself, rather than the county, would take additional effort; a Silicon Valley Financial Well-being Survey with Joint Venture Silicon Valley is expected to produce better local data in about a year.
  • An annual deferred maintenance backlog report, covering the storm sewer system among other things, is due to come to council in the next couple of months.
  • San Jose Clean Energy plans to reintroduce its vetoed PCIA transparency bill and keep advocating at the California Public Utilities Commission.
  • EV fast-charging hubs with pilot low-income and subscription pricing are due to come online in 2027; the Palante electric shuttle in East San Jose is expected to launch around the first quarter of calendar 2027.
  • Planning staff will revise the childcare land use regulations under the council's October direction.
  • Staff offered to connect council offices with the Turner Center for a separate briefing on its housing policy simulator.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: city.clerk@sanjoseca.gov or its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error