· 11 items
City Council, Tuesday, November 17
What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in San Jose's next episode.
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Tuesday, November 17
11 items
The recording · Agenda · Agenda · Agenda
Commendation: Regional Wastewater Facility's 70 years Item 1.1
Matt Mahan (Mayor) and David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) commended the San José-Santa Clara Regional Wastewater Facility and its staff for 70 years of continuous operation. 00:04:14
Proclamation: Ruby Bridges Walk to School Day Item 1.2
Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) presented a proclamation declaring November 14, 2026, Ruby Bridges Walk to School Day in San José, with remarks from the executive director of the African American Community Service Agency. 00:12:52
Commendation: La Raza Historical Society's 10th anniversary Item 1.3
Peter Ortiz (Councilmember, District 5) commended the La Raza Historical Society of Santa Clara Valley for ten years of preserving and sharing the history of Latino communities in San José; a member of its board accepted. 00:16:37
Orders of the Day: adding two late items
The council had to find, by a two-thirds vote, a need for immediate action to add two items to the agenda: item 2.20, an appointment to the fire retiree seat on the Police and Fire Retirement Plan board, and item 8.1, the pause on data center and large energy use project approvals. 00:24:10
- Unidentified member moved to add items 2.20 and 8.1 to the agenda; seconded. The chair called it unanimous of all present. Result: passed, unanimous. 00:24:47
Consent calendar Item 2
Development projectsLawsuits and settlementsAppointments and leadership
Routine items approved together in one vote, including final adoption of an amendment to the development agreement with Apple Inc. for property in North San José, a $180,000 lawsuit settlement (agenda), several contract increases, and the appointment of a fire retiree representative to the Police and Fire Retirement Plan board. No items were pulled and there was no public comment. 00:25:10
- Motion to approve the consent calendar, with David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) absent; mover not identified. Result: passed, unanimous. 00:25:41
Zoning and street code updates (PP26-003), land use consent Item 10.1(a)
Zoning and plansHistoric preservationHousing supply
An ordinance amending Title 13 and Title 20 of the Municipal Code to comply with state law and make council-directed and maintenance changes: revised tree removal rules in High and Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones, retaining wall height and permitting rules, historic resource inventory provisions under Assembly Bill 1061, accessory dwelling unit rules aligned with state law, vehicular gate permits, a revised definition of demolition for historic resources, a longer noticing period (10 to 20 days) under Assembly Bill 2904, and changes to reinstating legal nonconforming uses that eliminate the special use permit requirement (agenda). The Planning Commission recommended approval 7-0-4 on October 8, 2026 (agenda). There was no public comment. 00:25:44
- Motion to approve the land use consent calendar; mover not identified. Result: passed, unanimous. 00:26:07
City Manager's report: storm drains and El Niño preparation Item 3.1
Streets and public worksEmergency preparedness
The City Manager's verbal report marked National Stormwater Day, described the city's storm drain work ahead of an expected strong El Niño season, and promoted the Adopt-a-Storm-Drain volunteer program. 00:26:09
- Jennifer Maguire (City Manager) said the city has more than 35,000 storm drain inlets that move stormwater from streets into creeks and rivers 00:26:18
- Jennifer Maguire (City Manager) said catch basins, trash capture devices and street sweeping keep over 7,600 tons of oils, metals and debris out of the watershed each year 00:26:18
- Jennifer Maguire (City Manager) said clearing drains matters more as the city prepares for a strong El Niño season expected to bring heavy rain and flood risk 00:26:18
- Jennifer Maguire (City Manager) urged residents to call 311 to report weather-related problems 00:27:20
- Jennifer Maguire (City Manager) said more than 200 residents, schools and community groups have signed up to adopt more than 300 storm drains 00:27:20
Wastewater facility HVAC Improvements Phase 1 re-bid contract Item 6.1
Streets and public works
Adopts an addendum to the environmental impact report for the wastewater plant master plan and awards a construction contract to Blocka Construction, Inc. for $11,248,000, with a 15% contingency of $1,687,200 (agenda), for heating, ventilation and air conditioning upgrades at the Regional Wastewater Facility. No staff presentation and no public comment. 00:29:50
- Unidentified member moved approval; seconded. Result: passed, unanimous. 00:30:34
Black & Veatch owner's advisor contract for pump station improvements Item 6.2
Streets and public works
Approves a master consultant agreement with Black & Veatch Corporation to act as owner's advisor for the Pump Stations Improvements Phase 1 project at the Regional Wastewater Facility, through December 31, 2036, for up to $16,885,000 (agenda). No public comment. 00:30:36
- Unidentified member moved the staff recommendation; seconded. Result: passed, unanimous. 00:31:06
Non-exclusive franchises for clean-out and construction debris haulers Item 6.3
Trash and recycling
A public hearing and approval of 32 ordinances granting non-exclusive franchises to 32 companies to collect, transport and deliver residential clean-out material and construction and demolition debris, with agreements running January 1 through December 31, 2027 and an option for the city to extend up to three one-year terms (agenda). No public comment. 00:31:08
- Unidentified member moved the staff recommendation; seconded. Result: passed, unanimous. 00:31:48
Pause on data center and large energy use approvals, and urgency ordinance Item 8.1
Data centersEnergyZoning and plans
On a memo from Matt Mahan (Mayor), David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4), Domingo Candelas (Councilmember, District 8), Peter Ortiz (Councilmember, District 5) and Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2), the council directed the City Manager to pause land use approvals of data centers and large energy use projects until the council has approved uniform standards, and to draft an urgency ordinance for council consideration on December 8, 2026, so that the proposed data center ordinances and development standards take effect immediately on adoption instead of after the usual delay (agenda). The chair said the vote concerned only the pause and the urgency ordinance, not the standards themselves. About 40 members of the public spoke, just over half of them asking for a moratorium or more time. 00:31:49
▶ Hear it Is a pause enough, or does it need the force of law? · 0:50
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) moved approval of the item (the pause on approvals and direction to develop an urgency ordinance for December 8); seconded. The clerk first noted Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) absent; she returned, and the chair called the vote unanimous. Result: passed, unanimous. 01:36:20
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) explained that the item would pause approvals of new data centers and large energy projects until the council takes up the uniform standards on December 8 00:31:49
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) stressed that the item was not a vote on the data center regulations themselves, only on the pause and the urgency ordinance 00:32:52
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) credited Pamela Campos (Councilmember, District 2) with repeatedly pressing to make sure no project slipped through before the stricter standards 01:19:31
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) said urgency meant the standards would take effect as soon as approved, not that the council was rushing 01:20:36
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) said the standards process began in June and has run about six months 01:21:36
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) said the city's agreement with PG&E was being misrepresented a bit, and that it was about customer service and timely connections 01:21:36
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) said only about 13% of the city's land is for jobs, one of the smallest shares of any big city 01:22:37
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) argued that many other industrial uses, such as truck-heavy distribution, pollute more than data centers 01:23:40
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) said Monterey Park and others have adopted bans rather than standards, and that other cities are looking to San José for how to regulate 01:24:41
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) listed proposed requirements including 100% renewable energy and only tier four EPA-approved backup generators with strict limits on use 01:25:45
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) added that the proposed standards require closed-loop and recycled water, prevailing wages, and bar nondisclosure agreements and public subsidies 01:25:45
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) said the standards will go to the Planning Commission and that the staff memo was published November 10 01:26:50
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) argued that the pause would push any projects into the new year, which is longer than the 45-day moratorium speakers asked for 01:26:50
- Matt Mahan (Mayor) said the proposed standards include new fees on data center builders for affordable housing and for energy efficiency and sustainability 01:27:51
- Peter Ortiz (Councilmember, District 5) said including an urgency ordinance was crucial so the new standards take effect immediately once approved 01:30:05
- Peter Ortiz (Councilmember, District 5) argued that environmental protections are only part of it and called for strong community benefit agreements 01:31:10
- Peter Ortiz (Councilmember, District 5) proposed a San José Affordability Fund paid for by contributions from major developments, including data centers, and part of their new tax revenue 01:32:13
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) said developers' commitments were not enough and standards had to be written down for every project to follow 01:33:22
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) said no projects were immediately in the pipeline, but the pause makes clear none would be approved before the standards 01:34:25
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) argued that, with no approvals possible until the new year, the choice between a 45-day moratorium and this action made no practical difference 01:34:25
- David Cohen (Councilmember, District 4) said the standards will keep evolving before December and that no one could game the system in the coming month 01:35:27
Public comment
- Item 8.1 (data center pause): about 40 people spoke in person and on Zoom. About 22, just over half, asked for a moratorium or more time, often an immediate 45-day moratorium extended up to the legal limit (one speaker cited the legal limits of 10.5 months and then one year), some also seeking a cumulative public health and environmental impact study before standards are adopted.
- Many of the speakers seeking a moratorium called the draft standards inadequate, citing noise (including low-frequency noise), diesel backup generators, water and energy use, rising utility bills, heat, lighting effects on wildlife, and the lack of buffer zones near homes and schools. One environmental group asked for a ban on PFAS in cooling systems.
- Several speakers said community outreach had been inadequate. They noted that few residents knew about proposed sites and that the 1,500-foot notification radius is too small. Speakers came from faith groups, Mothers Out Front, PACT, the Sierra Club, Green Foothills, Alviso in Action, a bird conservation group and a Filipino advocacy group.
- Two speakers said other Bay Area cities, including Oakland, Gilroy, Morgan Hill, Richmond, San Francisco, Brisbane, Oakley and Hayward, have moratoriums or have paused projects. One compared the case to the council's recent extension of a moratorium on detention facilities.
- A few speakers criticized the mayor directly. One pointed to tech-industry money in his campaign for governor. Another speaker alleged conflicts of interest, improper actions and permit problems involving data center staff and a site in Alviso.
- About five speakers took the other side. A Silicon Valley Leadership Group representative called the pause reasonable and the standards balanced. Two construction tradespeople and a resident who works near data centers praised the city's work on the standards. One Zoom caller urged a no vote, saying data centers are essential infrastructure beyond AI.
- Open forum: nine speakers. A Veterans Commission member described this year's veterans events and asked for more funding for the Veterans Stand Down. Most of the others spoke about how the data center standards will be approved. They raised concerns that the planning director rather than the council would approve the standards, asked for the December 8 vote to be held in an evening session so high school students could take part, asked every councilmember to hold a district town hall, said outreach had been done only in English as far as one speaker knew, and objected to major decisions being scheduled around the holidays. One speaker was told mid-comment that data centers had already been discussed on the agenda.
What's next
- December 8, 2026: the council is set to consider the data center and large energy use uniform standards and an urgency ordinance that would make them effective immediately on adoption. Approvals of such projects are paused until the council approves uniform standards.
- The chair said the proposed data center standards go to the Planning Commission before coming to the council. The staff memo was published November 10.
- December 1, 2026: World AIDS Day flag raising at City Hall, with tower and rotunda lighting December 1-2 (agenda).
- December 1, 2026: the newly appointed fire retiree representative's term on the Police and Fire Retirement Plan board begins (agenda).
- January 1, 2027: the 32 debris-hauling franchise agreements take effect, running through December 31, 2027 (agenda).
Write to the City Council before its next meeting: city.clerk@sanjoseca.gov or its comment form